Community Forum

Ask anything about cases, applications and recruiting. Members and coaches answer.

SortRecent activity Newest post Most liked Video responses

The interviewer corrected one of my assumptions. Should I treat that as a bad sign?

Interview Feedback

During a case, I made an assumption and the interviewer immediately corrected it before I calculated anything. I recovered and the rest felt fine. Is needing that correction a meaningful mistake?

Oct 9, 2026United States

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Not necessarily. Interviewers correct assumptions for many reasons, including keeping the case on the intended path.

My first interviewer and second interviewer gave opposite signals about my performance. Which one matters?

Interview Feedback

After R1, one interviewer was very warm and said the discussion was strong, while the other was much more neutral and gave me almost nothing. I'm trying not to read into it, but do those signals tell you anything about the decision?

Oct 8, 2026United States

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Very little. Interviewer style is not a reliable substitute for the actual evaluation.

Two case partners are giving me opposite feedback. How do I decide what to fix?

Interview Feedback

I've been practicing with two people regularly and I'm starting to get conflicting feedback. One says I need to be more structured, the other says I sound too rigid. How do I decide what to actually change?

Oct 6, 2026United Kingdom

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Do not choose feedback based on which person sounds more confident. Look for the underlying behavior each person is reacting to.

If feedback says 'be more structured,' what should I actually practice?

Interview Feedback

I keep hearing the same vague feedback after mocks: be more structured. I am not sure whether that means my case framework is weak, my answers are too long, or my communication is messy. How do I turn that feedback into something specific I can work on?

Sep 30, 2026United States

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

First identify where the lack of structure appears: framework, analysis, brainstorming, or communication.

Recruiter said I was "close" after rejection. Is that useful feedback or just polite wording?

Interview Feedback

I asked for feedback after a final-round rejection and the recruiter said I was 'very close' but did not give much detail beyond that. I am trying to figure out whether that actually means I should make small improvements, or whether it is just a polite way to close the process.

Sep 24, 2026Australia

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Treat 'very close' as encouraging but incomplete feedback. It does not tell you which specific behavior kept you from the offer.

McKinsey feedback said my communication was not sharp enough. What does that usually mean?

Interview Feedback

I got rejected after interviews and the recruiter said the main feedback was around communication. She did not go into much detail beyond saying I needed to be clearer and more concise. I am trying to figure out what that usually means in practice. Is it more about rambling, weak synthesis, unclear structure, or something else?

Jul 10, 2026United Kingdom

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

That kind of feedback usually means the interviewer found your thinking harder to follow than it needed to be. The root cause can vary, but common patterns are long answers that never land cleanly, structures that are not signposted, weak synthesis, or analysis that is technically fine but poorly communicated.

How do you improve when MBB interview feedback is vague?

Interview Feedback

I got rejected after interviews and the feedback was basically 'good candidate, but needed more structure and confidence.' That feels too broad to act on. How would you turn vague feedback like that into an actual prep plan?

Jul 4, 2026Hong Kong SAR China

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Translate broad feedback into observable behaviors. 'More structure' could mean weak issue trees, jumping into calculations, unclear transitions, or a recommendation that did not synthesize the case. 'Confidence' could mean voice, pace, hesitation, or simply not committing to an answer.

Should you ask MBB for feedback after an interview rejection?

Interview Feedback

If you get rejected after an MBB interview, is it worth asking the recruiter or interviewer for feedback? I do not want to sound pushy, but it feels wasteful to walk away without knowing what actually went wrong.

Jun 30, 2026Singapore

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Yes, it is reasonable to ask once, politely and without challenging the decision. Some offices give useful feedback, some give only a high-level answer, and some cannot provide anything.

Got super vague BCG feedback... how am I supposed to know what to fix?

Interview Feedback

Got rejected after BCG interviews and the feedback was basically "good overall, but we needed to see more consistency in problem solving and communication." like... What does that even mean lol. Recruiter was nice but wouldn't give specific examples. I honestly don't know if my casing was the issue, fit, communication, or all of it. Anyone gotten feedback like this before? How do you actually…

May 6, 2026United States

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

This type of feedback is frustrating, but it is fairly common. Firms often give feedback at the competency level rather than walking you through every mistake from the interview.

Search CaseBasix

Community Forum

The interviewer corrected one of my assumptions. Should I treat that as a bad sign?

My first interviewer and second interviewer gave opposite signals about my performance. Which one matters?

Two case partners are giving me opposite feedback. How do I decide what to fix?

If feedback says 'be more structured,' what should I actually practice?

Recruiter said I was "close" after rejection. Is that useful feedback or just polite wording?

McKinsey feedback said my communication was not sharp enough. What does that usually mean?

How do you improve when MBB interview feedback is vague?

Should you ask MBB for feedback after an interview rejection?

Got super vague BCG feedback... how am I supposed to know what to fix?