Community Forum

Ask anything about cases, applications and recruiting. Members and coaches answer.

All topics Age Big 4 to MBB Boutique Consulting Brainstorming Cancel/Change Interview date Case Math Case Structuring Consulting Career Cool-off Period Cover Letter Data Analysis Experienced Hire Grades & GPA

SortVideo responses Recent activity Newest post Most liked

What if the interviewer gives me a number that contradicts the exhibit?

Data Analysis

In practice, my interviewer verbally gave me a number that didn't match the chart on screen. I wasn't sure whether to trust the exhibit or the interviewer. What should I do in the moment?

Oct 11, 2026United States

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Clarify the discrepancy immediately instead of choosing one source silently.

For market sizing, how do I choose between a demand-side and supply-side approach?

Market Sizing

For some market-sizing questions I can see both a customer-demand approach and a supply/capacity approach. How do I decide which one to use in the interview?

Oct 10, 2026Canada

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Choose the approach that uses the most reliable assumptions and connects most directly to the market you are sizing.

How much do first-year consulting analysts actually travel, and does it vary by office?

Undergrad

I've heard everything from weekly flights to almost no travel for new analysts. How much does travel really vary by office versus by project, and what should I ask before choosing an office?

Oct 3, 2026Australia

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Travel varies much more by project, client and practice area than the old stereotype of flying every Monday. Some analysts still travel frequently, while others spend long periods working locally or remotely.

How do I choose the right approach at the start of a case?

Case Structuring

I struggle with picking my approach to the case. How do I get better at choosing the right approach?

Oct 2, 2026United States

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Start with the objective and the decision the client needs to make, then choose an approach that directly helps answer that question.

How can I prepare for a Bain interview if my math skills are very weak?

Case Math

How can I prepare for a Bain consulting interview if my math skills are very weak?

Oct 1, 2026United States

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Prioritize the math fundamentals that actually appear in cases, then practice explaining your setup clearly under time pressure.

What is the best way to practice market sizing and actually get better at it?

Market Sizing

I want market sizing practice drills to get better at it. What is the best way to practice market sizing?

Oct 1, 2026United States

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Practice the underlying steps repeatedly: define the market, choose a sensible approach, make transparent assumptions, calculate accurately, and sanity-check the result.

How do I break into consulting in a country or culture different from my own?

International Applicant

How do I break into a consulting firm in a different country or culture from my own?

Oct 1, 2026United States

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Treat it as both a consulting recruiting problem and a local-market problem.

How do I make a recommendation sound decisive when there are still major risks?

Synthesis & Insights

My recommendations get weak whenever the case has unresolved risks. I end up saying 'it depends' and listing caveats until the actual recommendation disappears. How do you sound decisive without pretending the risks are not real?

Sep 29, 2026France

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Lead with the recommendation first, then explain the two or three reasons supporting it and the most important risk.

The interviewer was in a T-shirt on Zoom. Should I still stay formal for the next round?

Interview Dress Code

My first-round interviewer was very casual on video, basically a T-shirt and headset. I wore a blazer and felt overdressed. If the next round is also virtual, should I match the firm's casual vibe or keep dressing formally?

Sep 29, 2026United States

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Keep your own interview attire professional even if one interviewer dresses casually. Their clothing is not necessarily guidance for candidates.

Should I send a thank-you after a 10-minute recruiter networking call?

Networking & Coffee Chats

The call was very short and mostly logistical, but the recruiter did answer a couple of questions about the office. A full thank-you email feels almost too formal for ten minutes. Is it still worth sending something?

Sep 28, 2026United States

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

A short thank-you is appropriate if the recruiter gave you useful time or information, but it does not need to be formal.

Should I target a big MBB office or a smaller one as an MBA candidate?

I'm genuinely flexible on location and could see myself in either a major office or a smaller one. How should I compare big versus small MBB offices for MBA recruiting, project opportunities and long-term experience?

Sep 16, 2026United Kingdom

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Choose based on fit and the work you want, not on a simplistic assumption that one office size is easier to enter.

How long should my 'Tell me about yourself' answer be for MBA consulting interviews?

I have several years of work experience plus the MBA, so my background can get long quickly. How long should my opening 'Tell me about yourself' answer be in an MBB interview?

Sep 5, 2026United States

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

Keep the core answer concise enough to create a conversation rather than reciting your full resume.

I understand the idea of MECE, but I sometimes spend too long trying to make every case structure perfectly non-overlapping. How strict are MBB interviewers about MECE versus having a practical structure that helps solve the problem?

Jul 24, 2026Austria

Top answer Mayank G.

Mayank G.Coach

MECE is a useful principle, not a reason to freeze while trying to build a mathematically perfect framework.

Search CaseBasix

Community Forum

What if the interviewer gives me a number that contradicts the exhibit?

For market sizing, how do I choose between a demand-side and supply-side approach?

How much do first-year consulting analysts actually travel, and does it vary by office?

How do I choose the right approach at the start of a case?

How can I prepare for a Bain interview if my math skills are very weak?

What is the best way to practice market sizing and actually get better at it?

How do I break into consulting in a country or culture different from my own?

How do I make a recommendation sound decisive when there are still major risks?

The interviewer was in a T-shirt on Zoom. Should I still stay formal for the next round?

Should I send a thank-you after a 10-minute recruiter networking call?

Should I target a big MBB office or a smaller one as an MBA candidate?

How long should my 'Tell me about yourself' answer be for MBA consulting interviews?

Should my consulting fit stories come from before or during my MBA?

How do I answer why I'm leaving my current job?

Pretty sure I got rejected after R1 because my case math was too slow

How do I show leadership without managing anyone?

How do I finish structuring in under five minutes?

Messed up one option question in a McKinsey case. Am I probably done?

Any last advice for BCG Round 1?

How strict do I have to be about MECE in an MBA case interview?