A broad answer becomes weak when it is true in almost every situation but does not use the evidence in the specific case. Casey questions often reward the option that best explains the data at hand.

Ask which choice is most directly supported, not which statement is generally reasonable in business.

If one option needs fewer extra assumptions and connects more tightly to the question, it is usually the stronger answer.

Casey seems to punish answers that could apply to literally anything.

specific + supported beats safe generic answer.