It can be normal. Interviewers manage time actively, and direct challenges do not automatically mean your answer was poor. Sometimes they are testing whether you can adapt without becoming defensive or losing your structure.
The best response is to acknowledge the new information, adjust, and keep moving. This guide on the McKinsey first-round interview explains the broader format and expectations.
Judge the interview by whether you recovered and continued solving the case. Feeling uncomfortable is not the same as performing badly.